Score: 10

"I love this long song!"

submission: ==(Repairing a Broken Sky)==

date: August 6, 2008

I really appreciate how you made this song 7+ minutes, because not only can I listen to something uninterrupted so long, but your song is great! I love the layered pads, synths, and drums, and the sound they produce together. This is a great ambient easy listening track that I will enjoy for a long time to come.

Score: 10

"Good metal!"

submission: Killer Instinct [demo]

date: July 31, 2008

There are so many different melodies throughout the song, and each one is awesome! You are a very skilled guitarist!

Score: 10

"Grea vocals, instruments, and sound!"

submission: [SA] Far Away [Guitar Mix]

date: July 31, 2008

I rarely hear trance songs with such a professional sound on newgrounds. This song is not mainstream-sounding, not repetitive, and not a lazy effort. The song builds upon itself gracefully with each new part connecting perfectly with the previous. The singing is excellent, the synths and strings are harmonic, and the guitar is powerful. Great song!

Score: 7

"Honestly I didn't like it that much."

submission: {PhysX} Beat is Coming {RMX}

date: January 14, 2008

I heard nothing special in this song. There was a piano buildup, a lead synth, then a refrain with a heavy bass, the usual. I see a lot of people saying they are dancing in their seats and stuff like that, but I've heard more energetic trance songs before that are much more complex and interesting. Yes, the song sounds good, but the style itself is not unique, and so I've heard songs like this many times. I don't understand why this got first place, but I guess a lot of people like this type of music. For me, I prefer something more original and exciting.

Score: 10

"You are awesome"

submission: I'd Rather be Flying

date: January 13, 2008

I like how it sounds very relaxing. The progression is good throughout. And also, it sounded great in the game Ongaku.

Score: 2

"Not very good ... really"

submission: something else //glide

date: December 14, 2007

When will people stop making these generic trance songs? It makes me so annoyed! There is 0 creativity in this song, unless you count the terrible distortion which really hurts my ears.

Work on the overall sound of the song and try to make something unique, not just an overused trance anthem.

Score: 10

"Best Industrial Song!"

submission: Helix - No. 6

date: September 7, 2007

I was glancing around the Industrial section, disappointed at the sub par songs on the top. Then I come to your song, knowing it will be 10 times better than the rest.

I've always liked this song and even included it in a game of mine. Great work!

Score: 9

"Very nice song!"

submission: <:>The Painter of the Skies<:>

date: June 19, 2007

Wow! How nice!

I loved how the organ instrument slowly eased into the song, making the song sound very majestic at the end. The song was very harmonious and gentle, giving way to it's relaxing atmosphere.

Recommendations:

1. Make the song longer and develop it further, introducing even more instruments. If you don't want to make it longer, try making a better loop. My suggestion is have the song fade near the end until it reaches the volume of the beginning of the song, so the loop is smoother.

2. Improve the sound quality of the violin. The organ is perfect.

Overall, this song shows you have the ability to make an awesome composition! Thumbs up!

4.5/5 (I'll rate a 5)

Score: 8

"Good"

submission: PSO|Jungle Theme Remix

date: October 24, 2006

I liked this. It sounded great with the heavy bass and drums. The notes were good, except for one part with the almost- happy bass. The song had great transitions, and the pads were excellent. I like how they made the song spooky, with a slighty airy feel to it.

The beginning was excellent, setting the mood for the song perfectly.

I believe you could have included some extremely heavy drums at a few parts in the middle of the song, right after the leading- up instrument came in.

Overall very good. Not really the most enjoyable song to listen to, but it was made very well.

4/5

Feel free to check out my music

Score: 8

"Much better than yesterday!"

submission: Dj Svenzo - Zero Giving Twats

date: October 24, 2006

I liked this song much better. It was fuller, had a nice chorus, and the song progressed as it went on.

The instruments were better as well. The main lead was nice.

However, some parts went on a bit longer than they should have there could have been more note variety seeing that one main series of notes played the whole time.

Try to spend more time on your songs and they will become more and more interesting.

4/5